Barbara Richard

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

I heard an apt description concerning the evolution and development of a sociopath: "Genetics provide the weapon, environment loads the bullets, and life experiences pull the trigger." The genetics part of that metaphor would reinforce details of the Steven Stanko case, a murderer who is incarcerated on death row in North (or South) Carolina. He, being fairly wealthy, paid for tests on his brain, thinking to avoid death by proving he's either insane or brain damaged. The tests, including an MRI and others, concluded that the part of his brain that produces emotions like empathy, sympathy, conscience, and guilt, is not working. The pictures show a big blank spot in that area of his brain. To me, that makes him similar to a science fiction movie where a computer controlled device or machine develops a glitch and takes off on its own, destroying anything that gets in its way. It doesn't make him mentally ill by our definition, because he is an intelligent and highly functioning human being. But he is certainly mentally deficient to the extent that he cannot be allowed access to the rest of society. As I said, that would be like turning loose an out of control nuclear weapon. My opinion is that ALL of these people should be permanently incarcerated, because they cannot be rehabilitated. Technology has not yet invented brain transplants.

It also brings to mind the response of Gary Ridgeway (the Green River Killer) when Sheriff Dave Reichert asked him if he thought there was something missing in him. His response: "Well, maybe that 'caring' thing." Society shouldn't have to deal with such monsters.

1 Comments:

  • At 9:03 PM , Blogger Patia said...

    I've been starting to think that the whole "mentally ill" concept is a lot more amorphous and complicated than we think. Most people see mental illness as black or white -- you are or you aren't -- but I think there are untold shades of gray.

    Of course, people missing key components of the brain, like compassion, certainly do fall into the "black" category. (Not to imply any racist implications; it is an unfortunate cultural metaphor.)

     

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home